# What is the most overrated anime of all time?

> Being loved and being good are not the same thing, and this is where the difference gets loud.

*By YPB Team · Published September 5, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/what-is-the-most-overrated-anime-of-all-time*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **Sword Art Online** — score 1000/1000
   The trapped-in-a-game series that defined a genre and tops most overrated polls.
2. **Naruto** — score 875/1000
   A landmark shonen whose reputation is dented by years of filler episodes.
3. **One Punch Man** — score 642/1000
   A parody smash whose second season is the usual exhibit for the case against it.
4. **Jujutsu Kaisen** — score 577/1000
   A modern blockbuster often called an assembly of shonen parts done very well.
5. **Demon Slayer** — score 577/1000
   A record-breaking hit that fans regularly accuse of coasting on ufotable's animation.
6. **Pokémon** — score 500/1000
   The eternal franchise that fan polls keep filing under overrated rather than beloved.
7. **Death Note** — score 409/1000
   The gateway thriller that many argue never recovers after its halfway point.
8. **Neon Genesis Evangelion** — score 409/1000
   A canonised classic that a vocal minority reads as deliberately opaque.
9. **Dragon Ball Super** — score 409/1000
   The sequel series criticised for uneven arcs and runaway power scaling.
10. **Attack on Titan** — score 300/1000
   A prestige phenomenon whose final stretch divided even its own fanbase.
11. **Bleach** — score 300/1000
   A stylish shonen whose long middle stretch is a standing complaint.
12. **Tokyo Ghoul** — score 300/1000
   A horror hit whose later seasons are widely written off by readers of the manga.
13. **Your Lie in April** — score 300/1000
   A music melodrama accused of engineering its tears rather than earning them.
14. **The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya** — score 300/1000
   A 2006 sensation whose Endless Eight experiment cost it much of its goodwill.
15. **Black Clover** — score 300/1000
   A long-running shonen frequently named as more shouted-about than good.
16. **Fairy Tail** — score 167/1000
   A guild adventure criticised for repeating the same friendship-powered comeback.

Tags: tv shows, animation, japan, all-time