# What is the most disappointing Halloween candy?

> Some of these are handed out by people who mean well. The rest get traded away, buried at the bottom of the bag, or quietly binned.

*By YPB Team · Published September 20, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/what-is-the-most-disappointing-halloween-candy*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **Candy corn** — score 1000/1000
   The tri-colored sugar kernel that owns Halloween imagery and still ends up at the bottom of the bag.
2. **Necco Wafers** — score 963/1000
   Chalky pastel discs that taste, by wide agreement, like flavored antacid tablets.
3. **Raisins** — score 933/1000
   The small red box handed out by the one neighbor who treats Halloween as a nutrition lesson.
4. **Black licorice** — score 933/1000
   An aniseed flavor with no middle ground, handed out by adults who forgot children exist.
5. **Peanut Butter Kisses** — score 769/1000
   The taffy in orange and black wax paper that appears in every bowl and is claimed by nobody.
6. **Circus Peanuts** — score 755/1000
   Orange marshmallow lumps with a banana flavor that matches nothing else on the table.
7. **Laffy Taffy** — score 755/1000
   A stiff fruit taffy whose printed jokes are widely considered the better half of the product.
8. **Toothbrush** — score 666/1000
   The dentist's house special, technically a treat and universally received as a trick.
9. **Whoppers** — score 564/1000
   Malted milk balls that crumble into dust and stick to the roof of your mouth.
10. **Wax bottles** — score 564/1000
   Little wax containers holding a mouthful of syrup, after which you are chewing wax.
11. **Good & Plenty** — score 444/1000
   Pink and white capsules hiding black licorice, the most effective disguise in candy history.
12. **Tootsie Rolls** — score 444/1000
   A chewy cocoa log that promises chocolate and delivers something closer to sweetened wax.
13. **Candy buttons** — score 444/1000
   Sugar dots glued to paper strips, delivering roughly equal amounts of candy and paper.
14. **Smarties** — score 303/1000
   Chalky tablets in a crinkly wrapper that dissolve fast and leave almost nothing behind.
15. **Dum Dums** — score 303/1000
   Tiny lollipops in mystery flavors, the standard filler from any office reception desk.
16. **Bit-O-Honey** — score 303/1000
   A honey-almond taffy hard enough to threaten fillings and slow enough to end a candy run.

Tags: brands, food, candy, halloween