# What is the best Supernatural season?

> Fifteen seasons of brothers, demons, angels, and the road — from the monster-of-the-week early days to full apocalypse-level mythology. Which era had you hooked the hardest?

*By YPB Team · Published June 5, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/what-is-the-best-supernatural-season*

---

## Current results (1 vote)

1. **Season 1** — score 1000/1000
   The 2005 debut season introducing Sam and Dean Winchester hunting the Yellow-Eyed Demon responsible for their mother's death, establishing the show's core mythology.
2. **Season 5** — score 929/1000
   The 2009-2010 apocalypse season pitting Sam and Dean against Lucifer and Michael, crafted as the show's intended finale and considered by many the peak of the series.
3. **Season 4** — score 817/1000
   The 2008 season that introduced Castiel and the angel mythology, revealing the true scale of the cosmic war the Winchesters are caught in — a fan-favorite turning point.
4. **Season 7** — score 440/1000
   The 2011-2012 season featuring the Leviathans escaping from Purgatory and targeting the Winchesters, with Dick Roman as the season's corporate monster villain.
5. **Season 14** — score 440/1000
   The 2018-2019 season dealing with Michael's possession of Dean and his plan to remake the world, culminating in a devastating choice that changes everything.
6. **Season 8** — score 264/1000
   The 2012-2013 season with the Trials of God that could close Hell's gates permanently, Castiel's manipulation by Metatron, and Kevin Tran's doomed heroism.
7. **Season 6** — score 264/1000
   The 2010-2011 season following Sam's return without his soul, Castiel's war in Heaven, and the introduction of Purgatory — a polarizing but mythology-rich chapter.
8. **Season 2** — score 264/1000
   The 2006 season exploring Sam's demonic powers, the Gates of Hell, and culminating in John Winchester's deal with Azazel — raising the stakes dramatically.
9. **Season 11** — score 1/1000
   The 2015-2016 season introducing the Darkness (Amara) as the ultimate villain, bringing God himself into the story for an existential cosmic confrontation.
10. **Season 15** — score 1/1000
   The 2019-2020 final season confronting God himself as the ultimate villain in a series finale that brought a legendary fifteen-year run to its emotional conclusion.
11. **Season 3** — score 1/1000
   The 2007 season with Dean's deal with a crossroads demon counting down to his death, introducing Bela and the Ruby storyline in a tighter, darker arc.
12. **Season 10** — score 1/1000
   The 2014-2015 season featuring Demon Dean and the struggle to remove the Mark of Cain, with the Darkness looming as an ancient threat older than God.
13. **Season 9** — score 1/1000
   The 2013-2014 season following the fall of the angels, Dean's possession by Gadreel, and the emergence of the Mark of Cain — setting up a pivotal character transformation.

Tags: tv shows, horror, supernatural