# What is the best MLS rivalry?

> Hatred runs deep in some of these and is half marketing in others, with grudges older than the league itself next to derbies that only began in the last decade.

*By YPB Team · Published November 13, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/what-is-the-best-mls-rivalry*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **Sounders vs. Timbers** — score 1000/1000
   Seattle Sounders against Portland Timbers, a Cascadia rivalry that dates to the clubs' NASL meetings in 1975 and is fought for the supporter-run Cascadia Cup.
2. **Hudson River Derby** — score 843/1000
   New York Red Bulls against New York City FC, a New York-area derby first played in MLS in 2015.
3. **Atlantic Cup** — score 539/1000
   D.C. United against the New York Red Bulls, an original-1996 MLS rivalry contested for the Atlantic Cup trophy.
4. **El Tráfico** — score 539/1000
   LA Galaxy against LAFC, a Los Angeles derby that began in 2018 when LAFC joined MLS and Zlatan Ibrahimović scored twice on debut in a 4-3 Galaxy comeback.
5. **Hell Is Real Derby** — score 539/1000
   Columbus Crew against FC Cincinnati, an Ohio rivalry named after a 'Hell Is Real' billboard on Interstate 71 between the two cities.
6. **Florida Derby** — score 481/1000
   Inter Miami against Orlando City, an in-state rivalry played in MLS since Inter Miami's first season in 2020.
7. **California Clásico** — score 438/1000
   LA Galaxy against San Jose Earthquakes, a north-versus-south California rivalry between two founding MLS clubs dating to 1996.
8. **Rocky Mountain Cup** — score 438/1000
   Colorado Rapids against Real Salt Lake, a Rocky Mountain rivalry contested since 2005 for a supporter-created trophy.
9. **Canadian Classique** — score 385/1000
   Toronto FC against CF Montréal, a rivalry between Canada's two largest cities that has been played in MLS since Montréal joined in 2012.
10. **Timbers vs. Whitecaps** — score 385/1000
   Portland Timbers against Vancouver Whitecaps, a Cascadia rivalry rooted in the 1970s NASL and renewed in MLS in 2011.
11. **Texas Derby** — score 0/1000
   Houston Dynamo against FC Dallas, an in-state rivalry played since 2006 for the El Capitán trophy, a replica cannon.
12. **Trillium Cup** — score 0/1000
   Columbus Crew against Toronto FC, a rivalry played since 2008 for a trophy named after the trillium, Ontario's provincial flower and Ohio's state wildflower.
13. **Sounders vs. Whitecaps** — score 0/1000
   Seattle Sounders against Vancouver Whitecaps, a cross-border Cascadia rivalry between cities about 140 miles apart, played in MLS since 2011.
14. **Brimstone Cup** — score 0/1000
   Chicago Fire against FC Dallas, a rivalry contested since 2001 for a trophy created by the two clubs' supporters.

Tags: soccer, mls, rivalries
