# What is the best Halloween candy?

> Chocolate bars have the numbers, but the fruit chews have the true believers. One bowl, no settled order.

*By YPB Team · Published September 20, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/what-is-the-best-halloween-candy*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **Reese's Peanut Butter Cups** — score 1000/1000
   Milk chocolate cups filled with salty-sweet peanut butter, the most requested candy in American trick-or-treat bags.
2. **Jolly Rancher** — score 608/1000
   Long-lasting hard candies in loud fruit flavors that outlive the rest of the haul by weeks.
3. **Snickers** — score 518/1000
   A nougat, caramel and peanut bar under milk chocolate, routinely voted the most satisfying full-size handout.
4. **Sour Patch Kids** — score 481/1000
   Sugar-dusted gummy figures that hit sour first and sweet second, a modern Halloween-bowl staple.
5. **Twix** — score 440/1000
   A shortbread cookie topped with caramel and dipped in chocolate, sold in twin bars made for splitting.
6. **Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar** — score 394/1000
   The plain American chocolate bar that has been handed out on Halloween for more than a century.
7. **Starburst** — score 341/1000
   Square chewy taffy squares in four fruit flavors, famous for the pink one everyone trades for.
8. **Swedish Fish** — score 341/1000
   Red lingonberry-flavored gummy fish, a chewy outsider that quietly has a devoted following.
9. **Almond Joy** — score 341/1000
   Shredded coconut and a whole almond under dark chocolate, a polarizing but fiercely defended favorite.
10. **Nerds** — score 281/1000
   Tiny tangy crystals sold in a two-chamber box, a texture unlike anything else in the bowl.
11. **Milky Way** — score 281/1000
   Whipped nougat and caramel in milk chocolate, the softer cousin of the classic American candy bar.
12. **M&M's** — score 212/1000
   Candy-shelled chocolate lentils that top national surveys as the best-selling Halloween candy in the United States.
13. **Kit Kat** — score 212/1000
   Crisp wafer fingers coated in milk chocolate, prized for being shareable and easy to eat by the handful.
14. **Skittles** — score 212/1000
   Chewy fruit-flavored pieces in a hard sugar shell, the go-to non-chocolate pick for trick-or-treaters.
15. **Butterfinger** — score 212/1000
   A crisp, flaky peanut butter core in a chocolatey coating that shatters when you bite it.
16. **Tootsie Roll** — score 131/1000
   A chewy cocoa-flavored log wrapped in brown and white paper, the cheapest survivor of every candy bowl.
17. **Candy corn** — score 131/1000
   The tri-colored honey-and-fondant kernel that has symbolized Halloween since the 1880s and divides every candy bowl.
18. **3 Musketeers** — score 0/1000
   A light, airy whipped chocolate nougat bar that is the fluffiest option in the bag.

Tags: brands, food, candy, chocolate, halloween