# What is the best Andrew Lloyd Webber musical?

> From gothic mega-spectacles to rock operas and family-friendly romps, these shows span five decades of West End and Broadway history. Which one takes the crown?

*By YPB Team · Published July 15, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/what-is-the-best-andrew-lloyd-webber-musical*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **The Phantom of the Opera** — score 1000/1000
   The longest-running show in Broadway history, a gothic romance built around a masked composer's obsession.
2. **The Beautiful Game** — score 600/1000
   A musical set in 1960s Belfast following young footballers caught up in sectarian conflict.
3. **Jesus Christ Superstar** — score 494/1000
   A pioneering 1971 rock opera retelling the final days of Jesus, written with Tim Rice.
4. **Cats** — score 494/1000
   A sung-through spectacle based on T.S. Eliot poems, famous for the power ballad 'Memory'.
5. **Stephen Ward** — score 428/1000
   A musical dramatizing the British osteopath at the center of the 1960s Profumo scandal.
6. **Sunset Boulevard** — score 350/1000
   A lush adaptation of Billy Wilder's film noir about a faded silent-film star, featuring 'As If We Never Said Goodbye'.
7. **Cinderella** — score 350/1000
   A modern, witty 2021 reimagining of the fairy tale with lyrics by David Zippel.
8. **Love Never Dies** — score 350/1000
   The Phantom of the Opera's sequel, relocating the story to Coney Island a decade later.
9. **School of Rock** — score 257/1000
   A family-friendly 2015 stage adaptation of the Jack Black film about a fake substitute teacher forming a kids' rock band.
10. **Whistle Down the Wind** — score 257/1000
   A musical about children who mistake an escaped convict for Jesus, set in the rural American South.
11. **Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat** — score 257/1000
   A playful biblical pop-cantata and the first Lloyd Webber-Rice collaboration.
12. **Evita** — score 257/1000
   A rock opera chronicling the rise of Argentine icon Eva Perón, home to 'Don't Cry for Me Argentina'.
13. **Starlight Express** — score 143/1000
   A roller-skating spectacle where performers play anthropomorphic trains racing for glory.
14. **Aspects of Love** — score 143/1000
   A chamber musical about the tangled romantic entanglements of a group of lovers across decades.

Tags: broadway, musicals, andrew lloyd webber, theatre