# Top 29 MLB Players of the 1920s

> Sluggers who rewrote the record book share space with spitballers allowed to keep the pitch after the ban and Negro leagues stars whose numbers MLB now counts.

*By YPB Team · Published November 14, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/top-29-mlb-players-of-the-1920s*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **Babe Ruth** — score 1000/1000
   Hit 54 home runs in 1920, 59 in 1921 and 60 in 1927 for the Yankees, winning the 1923 AL MVP and three World Series during the decade.
2. **Ty Cobb** — score 961/1000
   Detroit's player-manager from 1921 to 1926 who batted .401 in 1922 and closed his career with the Philadelphia Athletics in 1927 and 1928.
3. **Rogers Hornsby** — score 917/1000
   Won six straight NL batting titles from 1920 to 1925, including a .424 mark in 1924, and two Triple Crowns with the Cardinals.
4. **Tris Speaker** — score 882/1000
   Managed Cleveland to the 1920 World Series title while batting .388 as its everyday center fielder.
5. **Hack Wilson** — score 836/1000
   Cubs center fielder who led the NL in home runs in 1926, 1927 and 1928, two years before his 191-RBI season.
6. **Lou Gehrig** — score 784/1000
   Became the Yankees' everyday first baseman in June 1925 and was named 1927 AL MVP while batting behind Babe Ruth.
7. **Grover Cleveland Alexander** — score 784/1000
   Won the 1920 pitching Triple Crown with the Cubs and struck out Tony Lazzeri with the bases loaded in Game 7 of the 1926 World Series.
8. **Oscar Charleston** — score 747/1000
   Negro National League center fielder for Indianapolis and St. Louis whose 1920s statistics are now part of MLB's official record; inducted into Cooperstown in 1976.
9. **Harry Heilmann** — score 727/1000
   Detroit outfielder who won four AL batting titles between 1921 and 1927, hitting .403 in 1923.
10. **Dazzy Vance** — score 586/1000
   Brooklyn right-hander who led the NL in strikeouts every year from 1922 to 1928 and won the 1924 NL MVP with 28 wins.
11. **George Sisler** — score 586/1000
   St. Louis Browns first baseman who collected 257 hits in 1920, batted .420 in 1922 and won that year's AL MVP.
12. **Paul Waner** — score 586/1000
   Pirates right fielder nicknamed Big Poison who won the 1927 NL MVP with a .380 average and 237 hits.
13. **Kiki Cuyler** — score 586/1000
   Batted .357 with 26 triples and a league-best 144 runs for the 1925 World Series champion Pirates.
14. **Frankie Frisch** — score 500/1000
   Switch-hitting second baseman who won the 1921 and 1922 World Series with the Giants before a trade to St. Louis for Rogers Hornsby.
15. **Joe Sewell** — score 500/1000
   Took over at shortstop for Cleveland's 1920 champions after Ray Chapman's death and struck out only 114 times in his career.
16. **Burleigh Grimes** — score 500/1000
   Spitball pitcher who won 20 or more games five times between 1920 and 1928, mostly for Brooklyn.
17. **Waite Hoyt** — score 500/1000
   Yankees right-hander who allowed no earned runs in 27 innings of the 1921 World Series and went 22-7 in 1927.
18. **Biz Mackey** — score 451/1000
   Catcher for the Hilldale Club who won the 1925 Colored World Series; elected to the Hall of Fame in 2006.
19. **Pie Traynor** — score 451/1000
   Pittsburgh third baseman with a .320 career average who won the 1925 World Series with the Pirates.
20. **Al Simmons** — score 451/1000
   Philadelphia Athletics outfielder who hit .392 in 1927 and led the AL with 157 RBI for the 1929 champions.
21. **Herb Pennock** — score 451/1000
   Yankees left-hander who won two games in each of the 1923 and 1926 World Series.
22. **Walter Johnson** — score 451/1000
   Washington right-hander who won the 1924 AL MVP and pitched four scoreless extra innings to win Game 7 of that year's World Series.
23. **Red Faber** — score 394/1000
   White Sox spitballer who led the AL in ERA in 1921 and 1922.
24. **Goose Goslin** — score 394/1000
   Hit three home runs for Washington in the 1924 World Series and won the 1928 AL batting title at .379.
25. **Tony Lazzeri** — score 394/1000
   Yankees second baseman from 1926 who drove in 114 runs as a rookie and was part of the 1927 Murderers' Row lineup.
26. **Ken Williams** — score 394/1000
   Browns outfielder who led the AL with 39 home runs and 155 RBI in 1922 and stole 37 bases, the first 30-30 season.
27. **Dolf Luque** — score 394/1000
   Havana-born Reds pitcher who went 27-8 with a 1.93 ERA in 1923, leading the NL in both wins and ERA.
28. **Urban Shocker** — score 0/1000
   Tied for the American League lead with 27 wins for the 1921 St. Louis Browns and later pitched for the 1927 Yankees.
29. **Stan Coveleski** — score 0/1000
   Won three complete games for Cleveland in the 1920 World Series and the 1925 AL ERA title with Washington.

Tags: baseball, players, mlb, 1920s
