# The 34 Best Columbus Crew Players of All Time

> Ohio's original MLS club has three championship squads, a Golden Boot winner and plenty of grinders who simply never left; weigh trophies against loyalty however you like.

*By YPB Team · Published November 13, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/the-34-best-columbus-crew-players-of-all-time*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **Brian McBride** — score 1000/1000
   U.S. striker who played for Columbus from 1996 to 2003, scored 79 goals in all competitions, a club record, and was the first inductee into the Crew Circle of Honor.
2. **Frankie Hejduk** — score 933/1000
   U.S. international right back who captained Columbus to the 2008 MLS Cup and scored in the final against New York.
3. **Wil Trapp** — score 933/1000
   Homegrown midfielder from Gahanna, Ohio, who made 205 appearances for Columbus and served as club captain.
4. **Chad Marshall** — score 933/1000
   Centre-back who holds the club appearance record with 277 games and was MLS Defender of the Year in 2008 and 2009.
5. **Justin Meram** — score 800/1000
   Iraq international winger with 43 goals and 234 appearances for Columbus across two spells.
6. **Cucho Hernández** — score 716/1000
   Colombian forward who was MVP of the 2023 MLS Cup final and scored 58 goals for the club before his 2025 sale to Real Betis.
7. **Robert Warzycha** — score 618/1000
   Polish midfielder from the club's first season in 1996 who holds the Crew record with 71 assists and later coached the team.
8. **Zack Steffen** — score 618/1000
   Goalkeeper who won 2018 MLS Goalkeeper of the Year in Columbus before moving to Manchester City.
9. **Diego Rossi** — score 618/1000
   Uruguayan forward who joined in 2023, won MLS Cup that season and has scored 51 goals for the club.
10. **Edson Buddle** — score 618/1000
   Forward who scored 52 goals for Columbus in all competitions in the early 2000s.
11. **Federico Higuaín** — score 618/1000
   Argentine playmaker who spent 2012 to 2019 in Columbus and posted 59 goals and 69 assists in all competitions.
12. **Guillermo Barros Schelotto** — score 500/1000
   Argentine forward who joined in 2007 and was both the 2008 MLS MVP and MVP of the 2008 MLS Cup final.
13. **Gyasi Zardes** — score 500/1000
   U.S. forward who scored 61 goals for Columbus from 2018 to 2022, including the 2020 MLS Cup-winning season.
14. **Aidan Morris** — score 500/1000
   Homegrown midfielder who started for the 2023 MLS Cup champions before a 2024 transfer to Middlesbrough.
15. **Harrison Afful** — score 500/1000
   Ghana international right back who joined in 2015 and won the 2020 MLS Cup with Columbus.
16. **Darlington Nagbe** — score 500/1000
   Midfielder who joined in 2020 and won MLS Cup with Columbus in 2020 and 2023, later serving as club captain.
17. **Stern John** — score 444/1000
   Trinidad and Tobago striker who won the 1998 MLS Golden Boot with 26 league goals for Columbus.
18. **Brian Maisonneuve** — score 444/1000
   U.S. international midfielder who played his whole MLS career in Columbus, with 208 appearances and 41 assists.
19. **Jon Busch** — score 444/1000
   Starting goalkeeper of the 2004 Supporters' Shield-winning team and a finalist for that year's MLS Goalkeeper of the Year award.
20. **Jonathan Mensah** — score 444/1000
   Ghana international centre-back who captained Columbus to the 2020 MLS Cup title.
21. **Yaw Yeboah** — score 444/1000
   Ghanaian winger who scored the second goal in Columbus's 2-1 win over LAFC in the 2023 MLS Cup final.
22. **Pedro Santos** — score 444/1000
   Portuguese winger with 35 assists for Columbus, who had six goals and eight assists in the 2020 title season but missed the final after a positive COVID-19 test.
23. **Duncan Oughton** — score 444/1000
   New Zealand international who spent his entire MLS career with Columbus from 2001 to 2010, including the 2008 title.
24. **Jeff Cunningham** — score 0/1000
   Forward who scored 74 goals in 243 appearances for Columbus, second on the club's all-time scoring list.
25. **Lucas Zelarayán** — score 0/1000
   Argentine-born Armenia international who scored twice in the 2020 MLS Cup final and was named its MVP.
26. **Kei Kamara** — score 0/1000
   Sierra Leone striker who scored 22 league goals in 2015, tied for the MLS lead, as Columbus reached MLS Cup.
27. **William Hesmer** — score 0/1000
   Goalkeeper who started for Columbus in its 2008 MLS Cup final win over New York.
28. **Ethan Finlay** — score 0/1000
   Winger who started all 34 league games in 2015 with 12 goals and 13 assists, earning MLS Best XI honours as Columbus reached MLS Cup.
29. **Artur** — score 0/1000
   Brazilian defensive midfielder who anchored the 2020 MLS Cup-winning side.
30. **Eloy Room** — score 0/1000
   Curaçao goalkeeper who started for Columbus in the 2020 MLS Cup final win over Seattle.
31. **Patrick Schulte** — score 0/1000
   Goalkeeper who started for Columbus in its 2023 MLS Cup final win over LAFC.
32. **Mike Clark** — score 0/1000
   Indianapolis-born defender who played for Columbus from 1996 to 2003, making 265 appearances in all competitions, second in club history.
33. **Eddie Gaven** — score 0/1000
   Midfielder who made 241 appearances for Columbus, won the 2008 MLS Cup and retired in October 2013, days after turning 27.
34. **Alejandro Moreno** — score 0/1000
   Venezuelan forward who scored the opening goal of the 2008 MLS Cup final for Columbus.

Tags: soccer, players, mls, ohio, columbus crew
