# The 27 Biggest Critic-Proof Box Office Hits

> Reviewers sharpened their knives for every one of these, and audiences bought tickets anyway. Some are guilty pleasures, others are franchise juggernauts nobody admits to loving.

*By YPB Team · Published October 31, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/the-27-biggest-critic-proof-box-office-hits*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice** — score 1000/1000
   Zack Snyder's 2016 clash of DC icons was divisive and critically panned yet grossed over 800 million dollars.
2. **The Smurfs** — score 943/1000
   The 2011 live-action and animated Smurfs film drew poor reviews yet was a big worldwide success.
3. **Five Nights at Freddy's 2** — score 786/1000
   The 2025 horror sequel drew even harsher reviews than the first film yet grossed several times its budget worldwide.
4. **Transformers: Dark of the Moon** — score 786/1000
   The third Transformers film earned weak reviews and still grossed over a billion dollars globally in 2011.
5. **Bad Boys II** — score 708/1000
   Michael Bay's 2003 buddy-cop sequel with Will Smith and Martin Lawrence was panned for excess yet out-grossed the original.
6. **Clash of the Titans** — score 655/1000
   The 2010 remake of the Greek-myth adventure was criticized for its rushed 3D conversion yet was a major hit.
7. **Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles** — score 524/1000
   The Michael Bay-produced 2014 reboot of the Turtles drew negative reviews but was a big worldwide success.
8. **Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides** — score 524/1000
   The fourth Pirates film was faulted by critics as tired but grossed over a billion dollars in 2011.
9. **The Da Vinci Code** — score 524/1000
   Ron Howard's 2006 adaptation of Dan Brown's thriller disappointed critics but was one of the year's biggest grossers.
10. **The Hangover Part II** — score 524/1000
   The 2011 Bangkok-set comedy sequel was called a lazy retread by critics and out-grossed the original worldwide.
11. **Grown Ups 2** — score 524/1000
   The 2013 sequel to Grown Ups received some of the worst reviews of its year yet was profitable again.
12. **Pearl Harbor** — score 443/1000
   Michael Bay's 2001 World War II romance was widely criticized for its script yet was a major worldwide hit.
13. **The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn – Part 1** — score 443/1000
   The penultimate Twilight chapter drew poor reviews and still grossed over 700 million dollars worldwide.
14. **Jurassic World Dominion** — score 443/1000
   The 2022 finale of the Jurassic World trilogy drew poor reviews but crossed a billion dollars worldwide.
15. **Suicide Squad** — score 443/1000
   DC's 2016 supervillain team-up was roasted by critics but became a major summer box office success.
16. **Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Squeakquel** — score 443/1000
   The 2009 family sequel was dismissed by reviewers but became a massive holiday hit.
17. **Fifty Shades of Grey** — score 443/1000
   The 2015 adaptation of E. L. James's erotic bestseller was mocked by reviewers and still became a worldwide hit.
18. **Fifty Shades Darker** — score 443/1000
   The 2017 sequel fared even worse with critics than the first film yet again drew huge global audiences.
19. **Five Nights at Freddy's** — score 443/1000
   Blumhouse's 2023 video game adaptation was panned by critics yet became a huge hit on a modest budget.
20. **Armageddon** — score 349/1000
   The 1998 asteroid disaster film starring Bruce Willis got rough reviews and became the year's highest-grossing film worldwide.
21. **Transformers: Age of Extinction** — score 349/1000
   The Mark Wahlberg-led 2014 reboot of the robot saga drew scathing reviews but crossed a billion dollars worldwide.
22. **Grown Ups** — score 349/1000
   Adam Sandler's 2010 reunion comedy was panned by critics and still became a box office hit.
23. **Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen** — score 238/1000
   Michael Bay's 2009 robot sequel was savaged by critics yet became one of the year's top-grossing films worldwide.
24. **Venom** — score 238/1000
   Sony's 2018 Tom Hardy antihero film was panned by critics but became a global smash and launched a trilogy.
25. **The Twilight Saga: New Moon** — score 238/1000
   The second Twilight film was dismissed by critics in 2009 but broke opening-day box office records.
26. **Godzilla** — score 0/1000
   Roland Emmerich's 1998 American Godzilla was trashed by critics and fans yet still made big money worldwide.
27. **Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales** — score 0/1000
   The fifth Pirates adventure got mostly negative reviews yet still earned hundreds of millions worldwide.

Tags: movies, hollywood, blockbusters, box office, critics