# The 19 Greatest New York Yankees Players of All Time

> The most storied franchise in baseball history has produced legends across every era. From Sultan of Swat to the Captain to modern-day sluggers — who defines Yankees greatness?

*By YPB Team · Published June 5, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/the-19-greatest-new-york-yankees-players-of-all-time*

---

## Current results (1 vote)

1. **Derek Jeter** — score 1000/1000
   The Captain who led the Yankees to five World Series titles, made 14 All-Star appearances, won five Gold Gloves, and became the franchise's all-time hits leader.
2. **Babe Ruth** — score 844/1000
   The Sultan of Swat, widely considered the greatest baseball player of all time, hit 659 home runs as a Yankee and won four World Series titles.
3. **Mariano Rivera** — score 771/1000
   The greatest closer in baseball history with 652 career saves, an unparalleled cut fastball, and five World Series rings as the Yankees' untouchable final out.
4. **Joe DiMaggio** — score 557/1000
   The Yankee Clipper whose 56-game hitting streak remains baseball's most unbreakable record, winning three MVP awards and nine World Series rings.
5. **Thurman Munson** — score 519/1000
   The Yankees' first team captain since Gehrig, a seven-time All-Star catcher whose tragic death in 1979 at age 32 cut short one of the most respected careers in franchise history.
6. **Reggie Jackson** — score 371/1000
   Mr. October, whose three home runs in Game 6 of the 1977 World Series stands as one of baseball's most dramatic individual performances.
7. **Roger Maris** — score 371/1000
   The 1961 home run king who broke Babe Ruth's single-season record with 61 homers and won back-to-back MVP awards as the heart of the Bronx Bombers lineup.
8. **Lou Gehrig** — score 223/1000
   The Iron Horse who played 2,130 consecutive games, batted .340 for his career, and delivered the immortal 'luckiest man' farewell speech at Yankee Stadium.
9. **Yogi Berra** — score 223/1000
   The beloved catcher-philosopher who won a record 10 World Series rings, was named MVP three times, and became one of baseball's most quoted figures off the field.
10. **Whitey Ford** — score 223/1000
   The Chairman of the Board, the Yankees' ace lefthander who won 236 games, posted a .690 career winning percentage, and was a World Series pitching legend.
11. **Jorge Posada** — score 1/1000
   The Puerto Rican switch-hitting catcher who anchored four World Series champions, a five-time All-Star whose leadership in the clubhouse equaled his production at the plate.
12. **Hideki Matsui** — score 1/1000
   Godzilla, the beloved Japanese slugger who won the 2009 World Series MVP with one of the greatest Fall Classic performances ever, cementing his legend in New York.
13. **Ron Guidry** — score 1/1000
   Louisiana Lightning, whose 1978 season of 25 wins, 1.74 ERA, and 248 strikeouts remains one of the most dominant single-season pitching performances in baseball history.
14. **Alex Rodriguez** — score 1/1000
   The controversial but undeniably talented third baseman who hit 351 home runs as a Yankee, won three MVP awards, and was a key piece of the 2009 championship team.
15. **Don Mattingly** — score 1/1000
   Donnie Baseball, the beloved 1980s first baseman and team captain who won nine Gold Gloves and the 1985 MVP Award in what many consider the peak of his remarkable career.
16. **Dave Winfield** — score 1/1000
   The 12-time All-Star outfielder who spent a decade in pinstripes, amassing over 200 home runs and 1,000 RBI as a cornerstone of the 1980s Yankees rosters.
17. **Bernie Williams** — score 1/1000
   The switch-hitting centerfielder and four-time Gold Glover who was a cornerstone of the 1996-2000 dynasty, hitting .339 in the postseason across his career.
18. **Andy Pettitte** — score 1/1000
   The workhorse lefthander who won five World Series rings as a Yankee, is the team's all-time wins leader in the postseason, and embodied quiet consistency.
19. **Aaron Judge** — score 1/1000
   The reigning All-Star slugger who broke Roger Maris's American League home run record with 62 in 2022 and won the MVP unanimously, becoming the face of a new Yankees era.

Tags: sports, baseball, players, new york yankees