# The 14 Worst Superhero Video Games Ever Made

> Licensed cash-ins, live-service misfires and one infamous fog-bound flight. Choose the game that let its hero down the hardest.

*By YPB Team · Published September 23, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/the-14-worst-superhero-video-games-ever-made*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **Superman 64** — score 1000/1000
   Titus' 1999 Nintendo 64 game of fog and flying through rings, the Guinness record holder for lowest-rated superhero game.
2. **Batman & Robin (1998)** — score 494/1000
   The PlayStation tie-in to Joel Schumacher's infamous film.
3. **Superman Returns (2006)** — score 428/1000
   An open-world Metropolis game with nothing to do and an invincible hero.
4. **Catwoman (2004)** — score 428/1000
   The tie-in to the Halle Berry film, as poorly received as the movie itself.
5. **Thor: God of Thunder** — score 428/1000
   Sega's 2011 tie-in to the first Thor film.
6. **Batman: Dark Tomorrow** — score 428/1000
   Kemco's 2003 GameCube and Xbox game, panned for its camera, controls and baffling ending.
7. **Marvel's Avengers** — score 428/1000
   Crystal Dynamics' 2020 live-service game, shut down after three years.
8. **Aquaman: Battle for Atlantis** — score 350/1000
   A 2003 brawler whose repetitive underwater fights sank it with critics.
9. **X-Men: Destiny** — score 350/1000
   Silicon Knights' 2011 action RPG, a rushed and short mutant story.
10. **Green Lantern: Rise of the Manhunters** — score 257/1000
   The 2011 tie-in to the Ryan Reynolds film.
11. **Iron Man 2 (2010)** — score 257/1000
   The movie tie-in widely called a step down from an already weak first game.
12. **Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer** — score 257/1000
   The 2007 movie tie-in with a cooperative mode few could enjoy.
13. **The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014)** — score 257/1000
   Beenox's buggy tie-in, pulled from digital stores when the licence lapsed.
14. **Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League** — score 0/1000
   Rocksteady's 2024 live-service shooter that cost Warner Bros. a $200 million write-down.

Tags: games, superheroes, worst