# The 14 Most Overrated YouTubers

> Huge subscriber counts do not guarantee universal love. Pick the creator whose hype outruns the work.

*By YPB Team · Published September 30, 2026 · https://youpick.best/ranking/the-14-most-overrated-youtubers*

---

## Current results (no votes yet)

1. **MrBeast** — score 1000/1000
   The platform's biggest channel, criticised for formula-driven spectacle.
2. **Zoella** — score 943/1000
   British lifestyle vlogger whose products drew mixed reviews.
3. **PewDiePie** — score 840/1000
   Former most-subscribed creator whose fame outgrew his early let's-plays.
4. **Jacksepticeye** — score 709/1000
   Irish gaming creator known for loud, high-energy commentary.
5. **Shane Dawson** — score 600/1000
   Early YouTube star known for conspiracy series and documentaries.
6. **Casey Neistat** — score 600/1000
   Daily vlogger whose cinematic style became a template.
7. **David Dobrik** — score 600/1000
   Vlog Squad leader known for fast-cut prank vlogs.
8. **Lilly Singh** — score 466/1000
   Sketch comedian who moved from YouTube to network late-night TV.
9. **Logan Paul** — score 466/1000
   Vlogger turned wrestler whose career has run from controversy to controversy.
10. **James Charles** — score 466/1000
   Beauty YouTuber and the first male CoverGirl ambassador.
11. **KSI** — score 0/1000
   British creator who spread from FIFA videos to music, boxing and drinks.
12. **Jake Paul** — score 0/1000
   Disney Channel actor turned YouTuber and professional boxer.
13. **Emma Chamberlain** — score 0/1000
   Vlogger whose casual style spawned countless imitators.
14. **Markiplier** — score 0/1000
   Let's-play star with a famously loyal fan base.

Tags: youtube, overrated, youtubers